Oaktree Capital Management · Q4 2025 · Published 28 October 2025 · Memo
Howard Marks reports on a U.S. state pension fund's board survey and what it shows about how institutional investment processes and portfolios are built.
Howard Marks describes a meeting with the board and senior staff of a U.S. state pension fund, where a consultant reported a survey of the board members' views, and gives his reactions. The board chose to bear less than all the risk the plan's finances would allow, preferred the normal risks of market participation to innovative but opaque strategies, and ranked beating peers last among its objectives. Marks argues that success for a defined benefit plan means paying benefits at the lowest cost to the sponsor, that volatility matters mainly for situational and emotional reasons, and that performance should be judged over a period that includes both good times and bad, not against peers or the actuarial assumption in a single year.
Before coming to that conclusion, one would need to gauge how the portfolio would have done if a different environment had unfolded – that is, to consider “alternative histories” in the way proposed by Nassim Nicholas Taleb in Fooled by Randomness.Show in the letter ›
Warren Buffett famously says he’d “rather earn a lumpy 15% return than a smooth 12%.”Show in the letter ›