Riverwater Partners · 2026 · Published 3 March 2026
Connor Doak argues that an investor with a concentrated, highly appreciated portfolio chooses between direct indexing, which realises gains at once but resets cost basis and allows ongoing tax-loss harvesting, and a Section 351 ETF exchange, which defers gains and suits large embedded gains, shorter horizons and estate plans that expect a step-up in basis.
Connor Doak compares two ways to diversify a concentrated portfolio with large unrealised gains. Direct indexing sells the positions, realises the gains and rebuilds index exposure with 100 to 500 individually owned stocks, which resets cost basis and allows continuous tax-loss harvesting and customisation. A Section 351 exchange contributes the securities in kind to an ETF, so no gain is triggered at contribution and the original cost basis carries into the ETF shares. Doak says direct indexing suits manageable gains, horizons of seven years or more and investors who want exclusions, while a 351 exchange suits very large gains, shorter horizons and estate plans where a step-up in basis may erase the gains.