Van Tharp Institute · Q3 2018 · Published 8 August 2018 · Essay or commentary
In Van Tharp's newsletter, D. R. Barton, Jr. argues the NYSE advance-decline line remains a valid breadth gauge though a third of NYSE symbols are not operating companies, as it tracks the S&P 500's own A-D line.
D. R. Barton, Jr. opens with a Highland Games caber toss in Scotland, where a lighter contestant beat the heavier favourite. He then takes up a debate over whether the NYSE advance-decline line is contaminated by bond funds, interest-sensitive closed-end funds, preferred stocks and other non-operating listings. He shows that about two-thirds of NYSE symbols are operating companies, and that the all-issues A-D line and stockcharts.com's operating-only S&P 500 A-D line look almost identical. He notes that two newsletter writers used the NYSE A-D line to call a market top in the early 1960s. In the trading tip, Van Tharp explains position sizing with a 1% risk rule and argues that position sizing and psychology account for more than 90% of performance.