Smead Capital Management · Q1 2026
Smead's Bill and Cole Smead argue that the S&P 500 cannot hold a permanently higher P/E because Microsoft, Alphabet, Meta and Amazon now earn less revenue per dollar of fixed assets as AI spending consumes their free cash flow, while Apache produces a 12.2% free cash flow yield at $70 oil.
Bill and Cole Smead test the argument that the S&P 500 can hold a permanently higher price-to-earnings ratio. P/E ratios have risen since 1982 as the 10-year Treasury rate fell from 14% to 1% and technology carried the index through several eras. Holding a high multiple needs the largest companies to keep their dominance and free cash flow. Yet Microsoft, Alphabet, Meta and Amazon now generate less revenue per dollar of fixed assets as they spend on AI. Apache, by contrast, produces a 12.2% free cash flow yield at $70 oil without adding fixed assets.
What we are seeing at Microsoft (MSFT), Alphabet (GOOG), Meta (META) and Amazon (AMZN) is that revenue generated per dollar of fixed assets is declining.Show in the letter ›
Now, we will switch gears and look at the long-term ownership implications of the free-cash flow of Apache Corp (APA) as the Iran War disruption has taken the WTI oil price to $110 per barrel.Show in the letter ›