2017 · Published 7 December 2017 · Speech, paper or interview
John Bogle argues, before the PCAOB, that the modern corporation should serve the public interest, echoing Berle and Means's 1932 book.
In a speech to the Public Company Accounting Oversight Board in December 2017, John C. Bogle revisits Berle and Means's The Modern Corporation and Private Property and argues that their model of owners and managers has become a double-agency society: corporate managers answer to money managers who hold 73% of stocks for other people and too often trade rather than own. He describes the rise in CEO pay, the earnings management at General Electric under Jack Welch, the silence of the funds in corporate governance and the growth of index funds, now 41% of U.S. equity fund assets, and Vanguard's turn to active stewardship. He proposes national governance principles and a fiduciary standard for money managers, so that investing serves the public interest.
Warren Buffett pointedly describes the typical consulting firm by naming it, tongue-in-cheek, “Ratchet, Ratchet, and Bingo.”Show in the letter ›
There are few better examples of this “numbers game” environment than General Electric Co.Show in the letter ›
Editor James Grant added: “the crimes to which GE allegedly stooped reveal a management besotted with its own share price.”Show in the letter ›
Chairman Jack Welch ran GE from 1981 to 2001, and left a legacy of accounting mumbo-jumbo to his successor Jeffrey Immelt, who divested large parts of the GE Capital subsidiary (a primary source of GE’s earnings management) and added several new lines of business.Show in the letter ›
Another encouraging sign of greater participation in corporate governance (especially to yours truly!) is the evolution of Vanguard, now the world’s largest index fund manager ($3 trillion) and second largest money manager ($4.5 trillion).Show in the letter ›
Intrigued by the idea, Warren Buffett offered to be part of it if I could persuade some of the largest fund managers to join.Show in the letter ›