Oakmark Funds · Q1 2026 · Market commentary
Bill Nygren asks why Oakmark, priced below even the Russell 1000 Value Index, did not gain more when value stocks outperformed in Q1 2026.
Bill Nygren asks why the Oakmark Fund did not do better in the first quarter of 2026, when value finally beat growth: the S&P 500 fell more than 4% and the Russell 1000 Value rose over 2%. Because the value index now includes many high-multiple companies, its semiconductor stocks, at an average forward P/E of 29, drove much of its return, and its highest-P/E stocks beat its lowest. He explains why Oakmark added eight new positions, triple its average and the most since the dot-com crash: prices diverged widely, and AI fears had cut the prices of financial advisers, insurance brokers and software companies, whose software stocks in the Fund now trade nearly 30% below average industrials.
This created a historically wide gap in P/E multiples between our portfolio and the S&P 500—and, more importantly, left Oakmark Fund’s P/E well below even that of the Russell 1000 Value Index.Show in the letter ›
With 50–60 holdings in Oakmark Fund, that implies fewer than three new positions per quarter.Show in the letter ›
Consider that the software stocks in Oakmark Fund now trade nearly 30% cheaper than average industrial stocks.Show in the letter ›