Riverwater Partners · 2025 · Published 17 February 2026
Adam Peck argues that the low-quality rally that began on 8 April 2025, in which high-short-interest small caps gained 32% while high return-on-equity companies gained 8.9%, left Grand Canyon Education up 1.5% against a 12.8% benchmark gain despite 9% earnings growth, and that the pattern after the last 10 bear markets points to quality leading again in 2026.
Adam Peck explains why quality-focused small-cap managers trailed in 2025. Citing Furey Research Partners, he notes that only 16% of core managers beat their benchmarks and that high-short-interest, negative-free-cash-flow and high-bankruptcy-risk stocks rose 32%, 24% and 23%. The gap between S&P 600 stocks and the rest of the Russell 2000 was the widest since the S&P 600 began in 1994. Grand Canyon Education, a top-five holding since inception, grew earnings 9% yet rose 1.5% while the benchmark gained 12.8%. Peck expects quality to lead again, citing small caps' discount to large caps, last this wide in March 1999, and forecasts of faster small-cap earnings growth than the Magnificent 7 in 2026.