Riverwater Partners · 2026 · Published 11 September 2026
Brian Gigl argues that behavioural biases, from loss aversion to the herd buying that put nearly 96% of retail GameStop trades after its January 2021 surge, explain why DALBAR found the average equity fund investor earned about 9.2% a year over the 20 years to 2024 against 10.4% for the S&P 500.
Brian Gigl pairs five behavioural biases with television characters: regret aversion with George Costanza, herd mentality with Cosmo Kramer, overconfidence with Cliff Clavin and confirmation bias with J.R. Ewing, plus loss aversion in a client who sat in cash from 2022. He uses the GameStop frenzy of January 2021 as the example of herd buying: the stock rose from about $4.30 to about $120 a share by 28 January, then fell about 80% within a week. A study of brokerage accounts found nearly 96% of retail GameStop trades came after the stock had surged, and the median late buyer lost about 13%. Gigl cites DALBAR's finding of a 1.2-point annual gap between fund investors and the S&P 500 and argues for a plan that keeps emotions from making the final decision.