The Journal of Portfolio Management · 2002
Low-cost funds beat high-cost ones by 2.6 points a year across Morningstar style boxes in 1992-96, and index funds beat active ones by 3.6 in large caps.
John C. Bogle repeats his 1997 study of mutual fund returns in Morningstar's nine style boxes over the ten years 1991 to 2001. As in the five years 1992 to 1996, the low-cost quartile of funds beat the high-cost quartile in every box by about twice the cost difference, and index funds beat managed funds on risk-adjusted returns. He adds that published fund returns overstate what investors earn, because of survivor bias, sales charges, taxes and the timing of investors' purchases, and concludes that gross return minus cost equals net return, whether markets are efficient or not.
The 634 funds for which Morningstar reported ten-year records represent the survivors of an estimated 890 funds that began the decade.Show in the paper ›
Several years ago, Morningstar estimated the survivor bias for each of its style boxes over the five-year period 1992-1996 (see Barbee [1999]).Show in the paper ›