Princeton University CEPS · 2004
A database built to limit bias shows hedge funds are far riskier and earn much lower returns than is commonly supposed, and many of them fail.
Burton Malkiel and Atanu Saha test the claims made for hedge funds, which typically use leverage, hold long and short positions and trade derivatives, and which are said to earn high returns with low correlation to stock markets. Working from the TASS database and counting funds that stopped reporting, they find that published hedge fund indexes overstate returns, because managers report voluntarily and backfill only good past results, and because so many funds die that indexes of surviving funds carry large survivorship bias, far larger than among mutual funds. Corrected, hedge funds earn less and carry more risk than commonly supposed; their low correlation with equities is partly an effect of stale or managed prices; a top-quartile fund is no more likely than chance to stay above average; and well over 10% of funds die each year. They still offer some diversification.