Princeton University CEPS · 2008
Fundamental Indexing's gains come from tilts toward value and small stocks, earn no three-factor alpha, and can be replicated with ETFs.
Derek Jun and Burton Malkiel test the claim that fundamentally weighted indices, led by Research Affiliates' RAFI index of 1,000 stocks weighted by book value, earnings and similar measures, improve on capitalization-weighted indexing. Regressing the index's returns on the Fama-French three-factor model, they find its excess return over the factors is zero: its outperformance in the 2000s came from tilts toward small companies and low price-to-book stocks, which a mix of equal-weighted, midcap value and large value index funds can replicate. Because price-earnings multiples had become compressed by 2006 and 2007, they expect value tilts to pay less in future and conclude that very low-cost capitalization-weighted funds should stay the core of an equity portfolio.
The best known of these new “fundamentally weighted” indices that claim to improve upon such deficiencies of a capweighted index is the Research Affiliates Fundamental Index™ (“RAFI”, FTSE RAFI US 1000 – Ticker PRF).Show in the paper ›
When Google was selling at $100 a share with very low current earnings, revenues, and book value, etc., it may have been “undervalued” rather than “overpriced” and FI will systematically hold less of it than it should.Show in the paper ›