Financial Analysts Journal · 2014
Counting expense ratios, trading costs, sales loads and cash drag, low-cost index funds build 65% more wealth than costly active funds for retirement savers.
John C. Bogle extends William Sharpe's comparison of index and active funds by estimating all-in investment expenses: not only expense ratios but also transaction costs, sales loads and distribution costs, and the cash drag of holding about 5% in cash. He estimates that actively managed funds cost about 2.27% a year against 0.06% for an index fund, so that at a 7% market return active costs consume almost 33% of the return. Over 40 years of retirement saving, low-cost index funds create about 65% more wealth, and for taxable investors the gap is larger still because of taxes on realized gains and investors' own poor timing.
Using only that measure, Sharpe compared the reported expense ratio of 1.12% for the average large-cap blend fund (unweighted by assets) with the ratio of 0.06% for the Vanguard Total Stock Market Index Fund.Show in the paper ›
Don Phillips, president of the investment research division at the mutual fund data provider Morningstar, described it as “preposterous.”Show in the paper ›