The Journal of Portfolio Management · 2011
Short-term speculation has overtaken long-term investment in U.S. finance, to the cost of investors and the benefit of financial intermediaries.
John C. Bogle argues that the financial sector has moved from a culture of long-term investment to one of short-term speculation, to the benefit of its own participants at the expense of their clients. He shows that annual turnover of U.S. stocks was about 15% when he entered the business in 1951, while trading now runs at some $30 trillion a year, about 200 times the equity capital provided to businesses. He traces the same change in mutual funds, from stewardship to salesmanship and public ownership of management companies, recalls Benjamin Graham's 1958 warning about speculation, and proposes four remedies: taxes on short-term trading, stronger regulation, a standard of fiduciary duty for the institutions that manage other people's money, and investors who look after their own interests.
A century ago, President Theodore Roosevelt distinguished between activities with positive utility that add value to our society and activities with negative utility that subtract value from our society.Show in the paper ›
In 1974, he left Wellington and founded The Vanguard Group, serving as chief executive and then as senior director for the next 25 years.Show in the paper ›