Financial Analysts Journal · 2009
Soft-dollar commissions spend fund shareholders' money on brokers' research and sales services, a practice that harms clients and should end.
John Bogle argues in the Financial Analysts Journal that soft dollars, brokerage commissions paid above the cost of trading in return for research and other services, are harmful and even indefensible to fund shareholders. A provision added to the Securities Exchange Act of 1934 after fixed commissions ended on 1 May 1975 made them legal. He recounts the SEC's actions from 2003 against five managers and brokers, settled for $192 million, and an NASD case over excess commissions of more than $98 million in which the fine was cut to $5 million. He expects higher fiduciary standards, fuller disclosure and more independent fund boards to end soft dollars, and holds up Fidelity's decision to pay for research in cash.