SSRN · 2005
Executive pay tied to stock prices rewards momentary price moves, not the long-run cash flows that make up a company's value, so options misalign interests.
John Bogle, founder of Vanguard, gave these remarks at a Columbia University symposium in October 2004 on Bebchuk and Fried's book Pay without Performance, and says he found almost nothing in it to disagree with. Paying executives through stock options ties their pay to the price of a stock, a perception with momentary precision, rather than to the value a business builds. Bogle splits stock returns into investment return, the dividend yield plus earnings growth, and speculative return, the change in what investors pay for a dollar of earnings, and argues that the speculative part dominated the 1990s, so managers took credit for gains they did not make. He blames the entrenched power of CEOs and the shift from owners to short-term agents who seldom hold a stock to the next proxy vote, and describes his own pay at Vanguard.
I heard earlier this morning that General Electric’s long-time CEO Jack Welch created $600 billion of value and was fairly entitled to, well, the moon.Show in the paper ›
I had not seen one until three years after the Enron scandal broke, and Jeffrey Immelt was rewarded on that enlightened basis.Show in the paper ›
And when my compensation got out of hand on the high side because we did so well at Vanguard, I gave back to the company, without any commensurate benefit, 40% of the shares I owned in that Partnership Plan.Show in the paper ›
I have been criticized for not being a picture of sartorial elegance, but so has Warren Buffett; it’s not because of money, we just dress the way we dress.Show in the paper ›