NBER · 2005
Simulated on 1871-2004 returns, a baseline life-cycle Social Security account ends with a negative balance after offset 32% of the time at retirement.
In this NBER working paper of April 2005, Robert Shiller reviews the arguments for the life-cycle personal accounts in President George W. Bush's Social Security plan, which resembles a plan President Bill Clinton proposed in 1999, and simulates the accounts with U.S. returns since 1871 and with international returns. Because workers who divert contributions accept an offset at a 3% real rate, the accounts amount to buying securities on margin. Assuming future returns behave like history, a baseline life-cycle account ends with negative value after the offset 32% of the time; Shiller concludes that the outlook is disappointing relative to the promoters' claims and that the accounts might help savers who invest too conservatively but hurt workers with no savings.
The Vanguard Target Retirement 2045 Fund is for people expecting to retire around 2045.Show in the paper ›