Journal of Policy Modeling · 2006
On U.S. data for 1871-2004, conventional life-cycle portfolios for Social Security personal accounts perform worse than their promoters claim.
Robert Shiller evaluates the life-cycle personal accounts in President Bush's 2005 Social Security proposal, under which workers could divert 4.0% of their 6.2% payroll contribution into accounts that move from stocks to bonds with age, against an offset that charges them 3% a year in real terms. Simulating contributions with U.S. data from 1871 to 2004, and with lower stock returns in line with other countries, he finds the baseline life-cycle portfolio disappointing: a real return of only 3.4% a year and a loss after the offset 32% of the time. A 100% stock account does far better on U.S. history, but Shiller argues the 3% offset rate is too high and that portfolio theory points to quite different optimal portfolios.
The Vanguard Target Retirement 2045 Fund is for people expecting to retire around 2045.Show in the paper ›
As of September 30, 2004, this fund had Vanguard Total Stock Market Index Fund 71.2%, Vanguard European Stock Index Fund 12.4%, Vanguard Total Bond Market Index Fund 11.0%, and Vanguard Pacific Stock Index Fund 5.4%.Show in the paper ›