Financial Analysts Journal · 2005
Gross market returns minus intermediation costs equal investors' net returns, so costs alone make beating the market unlikely: the 'cost matters hypothesis'.
John Bogle argues in the Financial Analysts Journal that the costs of financial intermediation take a large share of what markets earn, so investors as a group receive the market's gross return minus those costs; he calls this the cost matters hypothesis, beside the much-studied efficient market hypothesis. Over an investing lifetime of 65 years, an 8% market return less 2.5 points of fund costs turns $1,000 into $32,500 instead of $148,800. He takes his title from Louis Brandeis's Other People's Money (1914), shows that fund firms focused on a few funds outpaced most rivals from 1994 to 2003, criticises corporate pension plans such as General Motors' for raising their assumed returns as markets rose, and quotes Charlie Munger's view that money management adds no net value for clients as a group.
In 2000, for example, General Motors Corporation was projecting a 10 percent annual return on its pension plan, compared with the 6 percent assumption it was using in 1975.Show in the paper ›
Amazingly, General Motors was essentially saying, “The more stocks have gone up in the past, the more they’ll rise in the future.”Show in the paper ›
Warren Buffett's crusty but wise partner, Charlie Munger, shares my concern that in the field of money management, as far as the interests of clients are concerned, there can be no net value added, only value subtracted.Show in the paper ›