The Journal of Portfolio Management · 2019
Enterprise multiples predict returns through mispricing tied to investors' expectation errors, not higher risk, and the effect grows when sentiment is high.
Steven Crawford, Wesley Gray and Jack Vogel ask why stocks with low enterprise multiples, enterprise value over operating earnings, earn higher returns than stocks with high ones. Two explanations compete: the cheap stocks carry more risk, or investors misprice them. The authors sort firms by measures of fundamental value that predict returns after the usual risk adjustments, and find that the multiple's return comes mostly from the firms where investors' expectation errors are largest, that earnings announcements move value and glamour stocks the way mispricing predicts, and that the effect is stronger when market sentiment runs high. They conclude that the enterprise multiple effect is mainly mispricing.