The Investor's Shelf โ€” one book
A Money Mind at Ninety

A Money Mind at Ninety

Philip L. Carret, Philip Carret
1995
T2 248 pages ยท about 4h 8m to read OL3349747Wgoodreads

Reflections from a fund manager with a fifty-five-year record

Summary

Carret founded the Pioneer Fund in 1928, one of the first mutual funds in the United States, and managed money for more than sixty years. He wrote this short book at ninety, and it collects his views on investing, business and his own long career.

His approach was long-horizon fundamental investing with a preference for companies with strong balance sheets, low debt, honest management and reinvestment opportunities, bought at reasonable prices and held for very long periods. He held some positions for decades. He was sceptical of trading, of market forecasting and of paying up for popularity, and he emphasised reading annual reports directly and visiting companies. He also wrote The Art of Speculation in 1930, which is the more substantial book, and readers wanting his method in developed form should go there.

The reference has not verified the specific performance claims and anecdotes in this volume, which is a memoir written at the end of a long life rather than a documented record. The book is brief and informal, mixing investment observations with reflections on business ethics, taxation and his own habits. Its interest is as a first-hand statement from someone whose career spanned the 1929 crash, the Depression, the postwar expansion and the 1987 crash, which is a longer continuous perspective than almost any other investor has recorded. It is not a method book and it contains no systematic framework.

Key takeaways 7

  1. Holding good businesses for decades rather than trading them is what produced Carret's long-run results.
  2. Balance sheet strength and low debt matter more than reported earnings growth, because they determine whether a company survives conditions it did not forecast.
  3. Management honesty is assessable from how a company reports bad news, and it should be weighted heavily by an outside investor.
  4. An investor should read annual reports directly rather than rely on intermediaries, since the primary documents contain what the summaries omit.
  5. Market forecasting is not a useful activity, and a long holding period removes the need for it.
  6. Paying a high price for a popular company destroys more capital than buying a mediocre business cheaply does.
  7. Patience over decades, rather than any analytical technique, is the scarce resource in investing.

Who should read it

Investors interested in a first-hand statement from one of the longest continuous careers in American fund management, read as memoir rather than method.

About Philip L. Carret

Founded the Pioneer Fund in 1928 and ran money for seven decades through Carret & Company; died in 1998, aged 101.

The Art of Speculation, published in 1930, made the case for buying securities on appraised value with a margin of safety two years before Graham and Dodd's Security Analysis, which places it at the start of the value tradition rather than downstream of it. A Money Mind at Ninety records the holding periods, position sizing and management assessments behind a record spanning the Depression and the post-war decades.

everything by and about them

Where it sits in the reference 3

Investors
Philosophy
Styles

Who recommended it 1

Mohnish Pabrai's recommended reading list for investors

Similar books 6

Chosen by shared topics, the entries that hold them, and the people who recommended both.

Common Stocks and Uncommon Profits
Common Stocks and Uncommon ProfitsPhilip Fisher
The Art of Speculation
The Art of SpeculationPhilip L. Carret
Back to School: Question&Answer Session with
Back to School: Question&Answer Session with Business StudentsWarren Buffett
Business Masterminds: Warren Buffett
Business Masterminds: Warren BuffettRobert Heller
Investment Visionaries: Lessons in Creating
Investment Visionaries: Lessons in Creating Wealth from the World's GreatestPeter J.Tanous
Market Masters: Interviews with Canadas Top
Market Masters: Interviews with Canadas Top InvestorsRobin R Speziale