The Investor's Shelf — one book
Beyond Late Development

Beyond Late Development

Alice H. Amsden, Wan-wen Chu
2003
T2 223 pages · about 3h 43m to read OL3017088Wgoodreads

How Taiwan moved from imitation to scale in electronics and chips.

Summary

Amsden, whose earlier Asia's Next Giant established the developmental state analysis of Korea, wrote this with Wan-wen Chu on Taiwan's move into higher-value activities after the initial industrialisation phase.

The argument concerns what they call second-mover advantage in mature industries. Taiwan did not become an innovator at the technological frontier. Instead its firms entered products that were already established and standardised, and competed by executing them faster, at higher volume and at lower cost, with rapid scale-up and short time to market. The authors examine this in personal computers and components, in semiconductor foundry services through TSMC, and in other electronics categories.

The policy analysis is what distinguishes it from a firm-level account. Amsden and Chu argue that the Taiwanese state actively created the conditions: public research institutes, particularly the Industrial Technology Research Institute, absorbed foreign technology and transferred it to firms, and spun out companies including TSMC and UMC; science parks provided infrastructure; state financing supported entry into capital-intensive segments; and the state coordinated the scale-up that individual firms could not have financed. They argue that this was industrial policy of a specific kind, aimed at entering mature markets efficiently rather than at pioneering new ones.

They also examine the limits: Taiwan's firms captured manufacturing value while brand and design value remained elsewhere, and the model's returns depend on continuous cost reduction.

The book is academic and assumes familiarity with the development literature. Taiwan's position has since changed substantially, with TSMC becoming the technological leader in semiconductor manufacturing rather than a follower, which complicates the second-mover framing. The account of how public research institutes transferred technology to firms is the most durable and most transferable part.

Key takeaways 7

  1. Taiwan competed by entering mature standardised product markets and executing them faster and cheaper rather than by innovating at the frontier.
  2. Public research institutes absorbed foreign technology and transferred it to domestic firms, and spun out the companies that became industry leaders.
  3. State coordination financed scale-up in capital-intensive segments that individual firms could not have funded alone.
  4. Speed to volume production rather than technological originality was the competitive capability Taiwanese firms developed.
  5. Industrial policy aimed at entering mature markets efficiently is a different exercise from policy aimed at pioneering new ones.
  6. Taiwanese firms captured manufacturing value while brand and design value remained with foreign customers.
  7. A model based on continuous cost reduction requires continuous investment and offers no durable position.

Who should read it

Analysts and operators interested in how a follower economy moved up the value chain and in the specific role public research institutes played.

Where it sits in the reference 2

Countries
Philosophy

Similar books 6

Chosen by shared topics, the entries that hold them, and the people who recommended both.

Governing the Market
Governing the MarketRobert Wade
How Asia Works
How Asia WorksJoe Studwell
Taiwan's Economic Transformation
Taiwan's Economic TransformationTai-chun Kuo, Ramon H. Myers
21st Century Monetary Policy
21st Century Monetary PolicyBen S. Bernanke
A History of the Federal Reserve, Volume 1
A History of the Federal Reserve, Volume 1Allan H. Meltzer
A Political Economy of the Middle East
A Political Economy of the Middle EastAlan Richards, John Waterbury