The Investor's Shelf — one book
The Age of Surveillance Capitalism

The Age of Surveillance Capitalism

Shoshana Zuboff
2018
T2 704 pages · about 11h 44m to read OL18201749Wgoodreads

Behavioural data as the raw material of the ad model.

Summary

Zuboff argues that a new economic logic emerged at Google around 2001 and then spread, in which human experience is claimed as free raw material, converted into behavioural data, and used not primarily to improve services but to predict and ultimately to shape future behaviour, with the predictions sold in what she calls behavioural futures markets.

Her key analytical move is the concept of behavioural surplus. She argues that Google discovered, under financial pressure after the dot-com crash, that the data exhaust from searches contained far more information than was needed to improve search, and that the surplus could predict click behaviour. That discovery produced targeted advertising and a business model that requires ever more data from ever more contexts. She traces the extension into mobile, into the home through voice assistants and connected devices, into the car, and into what she calls the instrumentarian project of behaviour modification at scale, using Pokemon Go and Facebook's contagion experiments as evidence.

The book is long, written in a heavily theoretical register, and argues by analogy to Arendt, Skinner and industrial capitalism. Its central contribution is naming a mechanism and insisting it is a specific economic logic rather than a technology's inevitable consequence. Critics, including some who share its politics, argue that Zuboff overstates the predictive and behavioural power of the technology, that treating this as a distinct form of capitalism obscures continuities with ordinary advertising and market research, and that the prose repeats itself at great length. For investors the useful part is the account of how data collection becomes a business requirement rather than a byproduct.

Key takeaways 7

  1. Google discovered that data left over from serving search queries could predict click behaviour, and that behavioural surplus became the raw material of a new business model.
  2. Under this model user behaviour is not the product being improved but the raw input, and the product sold is a prediction about future behaviour.
  3. The business logic requires continuous expansion into new contexts, which is why the same companies move into mobile, the home, the car and the body.
  4. Prediction products become more valuable as they move from forecasting behaviour to intervening in it, which creates commercial pressure toward behaviour modification.
  5. Users cannot meaningfully consent because the terms are unreadable, the alternative is exclusion, and the extraction occurs in contexts the user does not perceive as transactions.
  6. This economic logic was invented at a specific time under specific financial pressure and is not an inevitable consequence of digital technology.
  7. Existing privacy law fails because it regulates the disclosure of data rather than the inference of new data from behaviour.

Who should read it

Founders and investors in data-driven businesses who need the strongest statement of the case against behavioural data extraction, read with its overstatements in mind.

Where it sits in the reference 2

Business models
Philosophy

Who recommended it 2

Book recommendations listed on their Good Books profile · aggregator only
Vinod Khoslareported
Book recommendations listed on their Good Books profile · aggregator only

Similar books 6

Chosen by shared topics, the entries that hold them, and the people who recommended both.

Chokepoint Capitalism
Chokepoint CapitalismRebecca Giblin, Cory Doctorow
The Wealth of Networks
The Wealth of NetworksYochai Benkler
What's Mine is Yours
What's Mine is YoursRachel Botsman
The Third Pillar
The Third PillarRaghuram G. Rajan
Accounting for Tastes
Accounting for TastesGary S. Becker
Affluenza
AffluenzaClive Hamilton, Richard Denniss