Closed-End Funds, Exchange-Traded Funds, and Hedge Funds
Academic review of the discount puzzle and related structures.
Summary
The reference has not verified this book in detail; the summary states only what the title, author and subject establish.
Anderson and Born wrote this academic survey covering three pooled investment vehicles and the research literature on each. The reference has not verified the detailed contents.
The subject connects three structures with different mechanics. A closed-end fund issues a fixed number of shares that then trade on an exchange, so the share price can and does diverge from the net asset value of the underlying holdings. That divergence is the puzzle the academic literature has examined for decades: funds typically launch at a premium, fall to a discount within months, and trade at persistent discounts thereafter, with the discounts varying over time in correlated ways across funds that no risk-based explanation accounts for. Exchange-traded funds solved this by permitting authorised participants to create and redeem shares in kind against the underlying basket, which arbitrages away any material divergence from net asset value. Hedge funds are private pools with limited redemption rights, performance fees and unconstrained strategies.
The research questions across these include the closed-end fund discount and the sentiment explanations proposed for it, the performance and persistence of returns, the fee structures and their effect on investor outcomes, the survivorship and backfill biases in hedge fund databases that overstate reported returns, and the liquidity mismatch when a vehicle offering frequent redemption holds illiquid assets.
The volume is a literature survey rather than a practitioner text. It was published around 2010 and the exchange-traded fund market in particular has changed enormously since, both in scale and in the range of strategies packaged into the structure.
Key takeaways 7
- Closed-end fund shares trade at prices that diverge persistently from the net asset value of the holdings, which no risk-based explanation accounts for.
- Closed-end funds typically launch at a premium and fall to a discount within months, which means buyers at launch lose systematically.
- Discounts across unrelated closed-end funds move together, which suggests a common sentiment factor rather than fund-specific causes.
- Exchange-traded funds eliminate the discount by permitting in-kind creation and redemption against the underlying basket.
- Hedge fund database returns are overstated by survivorship and backfill biases, since failed funds leave and successful ones are added retrospectively.
- A vehicle offering frequent redemption while holding illiquid assets carries a mismatch that only appears under stress.
- The structure of a pooled vehicle determines its behaviour more than the underlying holdings do.
Who should read it
Investors and researchers who want the academic literature on pooled vehicle structures summarised, verified against current market developments.
Similar books 6
Chosen by shared topics, the entries that hold them, and the people who recommended both.
Academic study of how discounts and premiums behave over time.
Doctoral treatment of the discount anomaly; narrow but the real literature.
How closed-end fund discounts and premiums work, and how to pick funds.
A yearly survey of UK investment trusts: research, opinion and data.
The UK trust sector's own blow-up: gearing, cross-holdings and collapse.
Second edition 2017 with Mark Etzkorn, titled A Complete Guide to the Futures Market.
Where it sits in the reference 1
Topics