Efficient Frontier · Q2 2007 · Essay or commentary
William Bernstein argues that high pay destroys investment skill: endowments beat other private equity investors by 21%, and investors should pick fund companies driven by craft rather than marketing.
William Bernstein asks who wins the trades that mutual fund investors lose, and draws on three pieces of research and the press. Marcin Kacperczyk and Amit Seru found in the Journal of Finance that fund managers who follow analyst recommendations do worse, and a Wall Street Journal article showed Illinois Tool Works buying small private firms at 1.1 times annual revenue. Josh Lerner, Antoinette Schoar and Wan Wongsunwai found that endowments earned private equity returns 21% above average, while banks and investment companies did poorly. Bernstein links this to cognitive psychology: internal rewards such as autonomy and competence sustain skill, while pay and bonuses erode it, as at Enron and WorldCom. He tells small investors to use public markets and to ask whether their fund company is a marketing company or an investment company.
The second piece of the puzzle appeared in the April 5, 2007 Wall Street Journal in an unobtrusive article by Ilan Brat on Illinois Tool Works, an industrial conglomerate that has done rather well buying up small private firms.Show in the letter ›
And speaking of successful money managers, while Warren Buffett has not exactly taken the same vow of "poverty," he does share Swensen’s otherworldliness, living in the same modest house for several decades, fitting out his living room at the Omaha Furniture Mart, and subsisting on Coke and cheeseburgers.Show in the letter ›
How else to explain the goings on at Enron, WorldCom or, for that matter, Dell Computer, once highly successful companies whose managements sought all the wrong incentives?Show in the letter ›
Far from it; were pay related to performance, then Disney, Time Warner, and Blockbuster should be the best-run firms in the United States.Show in the letter ›