Efficient Frontier · Q3 2006 · Essay or commentary
William Bernstein argues BRIC funds rest on a false premise: economic growth and stock returns are negatively related, and share dilution of up to 30% a year in Asian markets eats the growth.
William Bernstein criticises funds limited to Brazil, Russia, India and China and the Goldman Sachs paper that promoted the idea. He cites data from Elroy Dimson, Paul Marsh and Jeremy Siegel showing a negative relationship between economic growth and equity returns, with examples from England, Malaysia, Korea, Thailand and China. He gives two explanations: stock returns lead growth, and share dilution means per-share earnings grow more slowly than the economy. He cites Jay Ritter on managers taking wealth from minority shareholders and a study by Larry Speidell and coauthors that found dilution as high as 30% a year in Asian markets. He concludes that the long-term expected return of emerging markets is unknown, and that the asset class is useful mainly for diversification and occasionally cheap.
There is now a pretty impressive body of data from folks like Elroy Dimson, Paul Marsh, and Jeremy Siegel showing a negative relationship between growth and returns.Show in the letter ›
Rob Arnott and I wrote a piece on this topic in Financial Analysts Journal in 2003 in which we determined the leakage was 2.3% per year in the U.S. and higher in nations devastated by military conflict.Show in the letter ›