Efficient Frontier · Q4 2005 · Essay or commentary
William Bernstein shows precious metals equity returned 9.21% a year from 1963 to 2004 with a 0.29 correlation to the S&P, earning a 5% rebalancing bonus but with 24 years of zero real return.
William Bernstein revisits precious metals equity as gold becomes popular in 2005. He explains that rebalancing the asset class added about 5% a year, half its variance, because it has near-zero correlation with the rest of a portfolio. Using Ken French's industry data from July 1963 to December 2004, he shows precious metals equity returning 9.21% a year against 10.74% for the S&P 500, with a 0.29 correlation. He then shows the cost: five losses of more than 35%, one of nearly 70%, and a real return of -0.3% a year from October 1980 to December 2004. He concludes that the asset class helps a portfolio only for investors who can hold it through a generation of losses.