Efficient Frontier · Q2 2007 · Essay or commentary
William Bernstein weighs Jeremy Grantham's claim of a bubble everywhere: stocks at 20-25 times earnings are overvalued, and a flood of narrow ETFs could supply Minsky's displacement for a new bubble.
William Bernstein discusses Jeremy Grantham's April 2007 statement that he saw a bubble in every asset class, noting Ed Tower's finding that Grantham's forecasts ranked asset-class returns with an R-squared of 0.90. Bernstein agrees that stocks everywhere, at 20 to 25 times trailing earnings, promise low single-digit returns, but says that is overvaluation, not a bubble. He uses Hyman Minsky's two conditions for a bubble, liquidity and displacement, and argues that the flood of narrow ETFs is a financial displacement of the kind Minsky described. He adds two further conditions, that investors forget the last bubble and ignore valuation, and puts the chance of an ETF-led bubble at no more than even. He says the first sign would be ever stranger fund launches followed by ETF prices at premiums to their net asset values.
I make one teensie exception: Jeremy Grantham, one of the few folks who arrives at expected asset-class returns the right way—by looking at current valuations laced with realistic analyses of per-share growth metrics, viewed on a background of historical pricing.Show in the letter ›
Aside from the usual single country and slice-and-dice packages, there were, I kid you not, funds based on nine different NAREIT benchmarks, a "Dynamic Brand-Name Products Portfolio," an Inverse Materials ETF, a Healthy Lifestyle fund, an Ellioit Wave ETF, a Georgia (the state) ETF and, my favorite, an "Ultra-Short S&P 400 MidCap 400 Citigroup Growth" ETF.Show in the letter ›