Efficient Frontier · Q1 2009 · Activist letter
William Bernstein answers Joe Nocera's claim that Madoff's victims failed to diversify: diversification means owning many securities, and finance needs the training and practice standards other professions have.
William Bernstein replies to Joe Nocera's New York Times column of March 14, 2009, which blamed Bernie Madoff's victims for putting their money with one manager. Bernstein says diversification means spreading money across many securities, which a few index funds can do, not across fund companies or advisors. He argues that the Investment Company Act of 1940 protects mutual fund investors against fraud. He compares finance with medicine, law and accounting, which regulate training and practice, and notes that stockbrokers are not fiduciaries. He calls for minimum standards for advisors and brokers and for restricting hedge funds to the most sophisticated institutional investors.
An investor who can buy an index fund from Vanguard or Fidelity, or a total-market ETF from Barclay’s, would have to be out of his mind to buy more expensive funds from additional companies in the name of "diversification."Show in the letter ›
If Bernie Madoff’s unfortunate clients are guilty of anything, Joe, it is of naively expecting their government to provide the same sort of protections that they get when they have their drains repaired or their teeth drilled.Show in the letter ›