Efficient Frontier · Q2 2006 · Essay or commentary
William Bernstein's three-factor regressions show that slightly under two-thirds of the RAFI's 197 basis-point lead over the S&P 500 from 1962 to 2004 came from value exposure.
William Bernstein examines the fundamental index of Rob Arnott, Jason Hsu and Philip Moore, which weights the 1,000 largest companies by earnings, sales, book value, dividends and employees. Their composite RAFI beat the S&P 500 by 197 basis points a year from 1962 to 2004. Bernstein ran Fama-French three-factor regressions of the RAFI and the Fama-French large value and large growth indexes over the same period. The RAFI's value loading of 0.36 times a value premium of 5.08% a year explains 1.83% of its excess return, and crediting it for the negative alpha of large value stocks adds about 72 basis points. He concludes that the technique adds a small, statistically insignificant edge, which costs and fees could easily erase.
The results were impressive: between 1962 and 2004, the annualized return of their composite RAFI (Research Affiliates Fundamental 1000 Index) outpaced the S&P 500 by 197 basis points (bp).Show in the letter ›
A year ago, Rob Arnott, Jason Hsu, and Philip Moore published a piece in Financial Analysts Journal , "Fundamental Indexation," in which they describe a novel way of attacking the well-known tendency of market-cap indexing to overweight large growth stocks.Show in the letter ›