Efficient Frontier · Q3 2005 · Essay or commentary
William Bernstein concedes two errors: the January effect in small stocks persists, and Barclays' country iShares, which all lagged their MSCI indexes in 1999, now track them with an average 0.79% gain.
William Bernstein reviews nine years of his Efficient Frontier writing and names two calls he got wrong. In 1999 he criticised Mark Hulbert on the January effect, and in 2000 he criticised Barclays' foreign country ETFs for tracking errors. Using Fama-French data in ten-year periods, he finds the January premium in small stocks has weakened in the U.S. but not disappeared, while the January value premium is unclear and of little practical use after costs. He then shows that Barclays' country iShares, all 17 of which had lagged their MSCI indexes, have since October 1999 mostly beaten them. He offers two explanations, better trading or the 5% single-stock limit, and still sees little place for country funds in most portfolios.