Efficient Frontier · Q3 2006 · Essay or commentary
William Bernstein argues the 11.18% historical return on commodity futures came from producers hedging against deflation; with funds now buying inflation insurance, that premium has turned to contango.
William Bernstein reviews a working paper by Gary Gorton and Geert Rouwenhorst on commodity returns from July 1959 to December 2004. Spot commodities returned 3.47% a year, rebalancing raised that to 6.66%, and rebalanced futures returned 11.18%, above the S&P 500's 10.48%, with lower volatility and zero to negative correlation with stocks. Bernstein explains the extra return as Keynesian normal backwardation: producers hedging against falling prices paid speculators a premium. He argues that today the largest buyers, such as PIMCO and Goldman Sachs funds, seek insurance against inflation, so futures trade in contango and the premium goes the other way. A postscript recommends a paper by Dimson, Marsh and Staunton on the global equity risk premium.
If you want a superb overview of the topic, I highly recommend a working paper by Gary Gorton and Geert Rouwenhorst of Wharton and Yale, respectively.Show in the letter ›
Now the largest offers are coming, ultimately, from folks with names like PIMCO and Goldman Sachs.Show in the letter ›