Counterpoint Global, Morgan Stanley · 2024 · Published 23 April 2024 · Research paper
Michael Mauboussin explains what valuation multiples miss, why they differ across companies, and how they link to growth, return on capital and risk.
Michael Mauboussin and Dan Callahan examine valuation multiples, which nearly 93 percent of analysts in one survey said they use, and link them to the fundamentals that drive value. They show what multiples miss, such as investment in intangible assets expensed through the income statement, why the two most popular, P/E and EV/EBITDA, can send different signals, using Walmart and Apple as an example, and how growth, return on capital, capital structure and taxes determine what a multiple should be. They encourage analysts who use multiples to understand the value drivers behind them.
Aswath Damodaran, a professor of finance at the Stern School at New York University, likes to distinguish between “pricing” and “valuing” companies.Show in the letter ›
The P/E multiple, based on earnings estimated for the next twelve months, was 25.5 for Walmart and 25.4 for Apple.Show in the letter ›
The ratio of P/E to EV/EBITDA was 1.9 times for Walmart and 1.3 times for Apple.Show in the letter ›
Finally, Walmart has a tax rate that is 10 percentage points higher than that of Apple.Show in the letter ›
Unrealized investment gains or losses, which can be more than $5 billion a day for Berkshire Hathaway, explain most of the difference between GAAP earnings and operating earnings.Show in the letter ›