Financial Analysts Journal · 2009
An interview on the 2008 crisis argues that financial innovation has mostly served the innovators rather than investors.
In an interview with Rodney N. Sullivan of the Financial Analysts Journal in October 2008, John Bogle describes the financial crisis as a black swan event and blames institutions that abandoned their principles and their principals. He argues that derivatives let investors gamble on prices and credit defaults in ways that are unrecorded, that the profits of innovation were privatized while the risk was socialized through Fannie Mae, Freddie Mac and the banks, and that fund turnover of 80 percent implies a holding period of about 15 months. He expects bonds to return about 5 percent and stocks about 10.5 percent, from a 3.5 percent dividend yield and 7 percent earnings growth.
We were warned about this by former Fed chairman Alan Greenspan.Show in the paper ›
The profits of innovation and growth are privatized, but it now turns out that we’ve socialized the risk—whether it’s the Federal National Mortgage Association (Fannie Mae) and the Federal Home Loan Mortgage Corporation (Freddie Mac) or the entire banking system.Show in the paper ›
It has to be done by the government, but I hope it is done wisely—maybe by a quasi-governmental organization, a Federal Reserve–type institution, rather than the federal government itself.Show in the paper ›