The Journal of Portfolio Management · 2009
The 2008 crisis traces largely to managers' failure to put clients first, the fiduciary principle Justice Harlan Stone defended in 1934.
John C. Bogle takes his theme from Harlan Fiske Stone's 1934 address, "No man can serve two masters," and argues that institutional managers, who now own 75% of the shares of U.S. public corporations against about 8% half a century ago, have neglected their fiduciary duty to the investors whose money they manage. He lists the fund industry's conflicts: boards run by management company executives, fees far above those charged to pension funds and heavy advertising paid by existing shareholders. He describes how he built Vanguard as a mutual fund firm owned by its funds and run at cost, and calls for a federal standard of fiduciary duty for institutional money managers.
And we seem to have forgotten Benjamin Graham’s [2003] implicit caution about the transience of short-term perception, compared to the durability of long-term reality: “In the short run, the stock market is a voting machine; in the long run it is a weighing machine” (p.Show in the paper ›
My candor may well have played a supporting role in my dismissal as chief executive of Wellington Management Company in January 1974.Show in the paper ›
Our new structure involved the creation of a new firm, The Vanguard Group of Investment Companies, owned by the funds, employing their own officers and staff, and operated on an at-cost basis, a truly mutual mutual fund firm.Show in the paper ›
Vanguard represented my best effort to align the interests of fund investors and fund managers under established principles of fiduciary duty.Show in the paper ›
Consider this warning from Adam Smith way back in the 18th century: “Managers of other people’s money (rarely) watch over it with the same anxious vigilance with which … they watch over their own … [T]hey very easily give themselves a dispensation.Show in the paper ›