Financial Analysts Journal · 2005
Since 1945 the fund industry has moved from stewardship to salesmanship, with more risk, higher turnover, shorter holding periods and passive governance.
For the Financial Analysts Journal's 60th anniversary, John C. Bogle argues that the changes in the mutual fund industry since 1945 have benefited managers, not investors. Fund assets grew from $882 million to $7.5 trillion; investment committees gave way to star portfolio managers; turnover rose until the average stock is held for only 11 months; investors' redemptions reached 41% of assets; and fees at the 25 largest managers rose 6,600-fold while assets rose 3,600-fold. Public ownership of management companies put their profits ahead of shareholders, and fund investors, through poor timing and fund selection, earned far less than the funds and the market.
A few portfolio managers actually were stars—Fidelity Investment’s Peter Lynch, Vanguard’s John Neff, Legg Mason’s Bill Miller, for example—but most proved to be comets, illuminating the fund firmament for but a moment before flaming out.Show in the paper ›
Mutual funds, once stock owners, became stock traders and moved far away from what Warren Buffett describes as his favorite holding period: Forever.Show in the paper ›
Investors bought management company shares for the same reasons that they bought shares of Microsoft Corporation and IBM Corporation and, for that matter, Enron: Because they thought their earnings would grow and their stock prices would rise accordingly.Show in the paper ›
Today, among the fifty largest fund managers, only eight remain privately held (plus mutually owned Vanguard).Show in the paper ›