The Investor's Shelf — one book
The Limits to Growth

The Limits to Growth

Donella H. Meadows, Dennis L. Meadows, Jorgen Randers
1972
T2 207 pages · about 3h 27m to read OL3737039Wgoodreads

Summary

Donella Meadows, Dennis Meadows, Jorgen Randers and William Behrens built a computer model called World3 at MIT and published its results for the Club of Rome in 1972. The book sold millions of copies and provoked a debate that has continued for fifty years.

The model links five variables: population, food production, industrialisation, pollution and consumption of non-renewable resources. Its structure incorporates exponential growth in several of these, physical limits on others, and delays in the feedback between them. The central finding is that under most parameter sets the system overshoots its limits and then declines, and that the delays are what produce the overshoot: by the time the constraint becomes visible, the momentum in the system carries it past the sustainable level. The authors ran scenarios including higher resource availability, better pollution control and improved agricultural yields, and found that these postponed rather than prevented the overshoot unless growth itself was addressed.

The book was widely misrepresented as predicting specific resource exhaustion by specific dates, which it did not do; it presented scenarios rather than forecasts. Economists including Julian Simon attacked the treatment of prices, substitution and technological response, which the model handles crudely, and the failure of resource prices to rise as predicted was treated as a refutation. Later comparisons of the standard run against actual data, including work by Graham Turner, found closer correspondence than the book's critics acknowledge. The methodological point about delay and overshoot in systems with exponential growth is the durable contribution.

Key takeaways 7

  1. Systems combining exponential growth with physical limits and delayed feedback overshoot their sustainable level before the constraint becomes visible.
  2. Delay in the feedback between consumption and its consequences is what produces overshoot rather than smooth adjustment.
  3. Increasing resource availability or improving pollution control postpones overshoot rather than preventing it, because growth continues.
  4. The authors presented scenarios rather than forecasts, and the book was widely misrepresented as predicting dated resource exhaustion.
  5. Economists attacked the model's crude treatment of prices, substitution and technological response, which is its genuine weakness.
  6. Later comparisons of the standard run against actual data found closer correspondence than the book's critics acknowledge.
  7. Addressing growth itself rather than its individual consequences is the only intervention the model finds effective.

Who should read it

Investors and analysts who want the original systems argument about growth and limits rather than the caricature of it in the subsequent debate.

Where it sits in the reference 2

Mental models
Mental models

Similar books 6

Chosen by shared topics, the entries that hold them, and the people who recommended both.

Thinking in Systems
Thinking in SystemsDonella H. Meadows
Collapse
CollapseJared Diamond
Complexity: The Emerging Science at the Edge
Complexity: The Emerging Science at the Edge of Order and ChaosM. Mitchell Waldrop
Consilience
ConsilienceEdward O. Wilson
Cybernetics
CyberneticsNorbert Wiener
Living Within Limits
Living Within LimitsGarrett Hardin