The Investor's Shelf — one book
The Monk and the Riddle

The Monk and the Riddle

Randy Komisar
2000
192 pages · about 3h 12m to read OL16306444Wgoodreads

Summary

Komisar was a Silicon Valley executive and venture partner who described his role as virtual chief executive officer, working with several startups at once without running any of them. The book combines a fictional narrative, in which he advises a founder pitching an online funeral services business, with reflections on what he learned from LucasArts, Claris, WebTV and TiVo.

The central concept is what he calls the deferred life plan, meaning the arrangement in which a person does work they do not care about in order to earn the position to do what they want later. Komisar argues that this trade rarely completes, that the first stage consumes the years and forms habits that make the second stage unreachable, and that founders in particular adopt it in the specific form of building a company they do not care about in order to become wealthy enough to do something they do.

The business content concerns what makes a startup worth building. Komisar pushes the fictional founder from a business plan optimised for exit toward a proposition he actually cares about, on the argument that the difficulty of building a company exceeds what a purely financial motive will sustain. He also covers the differences between the chief executive, the founder and the investor roles, and what a company actually needs from each.

The book is short and the fictional device is thin. It comes from the 1998 to 2000 period and the specific market conditions are gone. It offers no method and is closer to an argument about motivation. The deferred life plan is the concept that has persisted and it applies well beyond startups.

Key takeaways 8

  1. The deferred life plan, in which a person does work they do not care about in order to earn the right to do what they want later, rarely completes.
  2. The first stage of a deferred life plan consumes the years and forms habits that make the second stage unreachable.
  3. Building a company is difficult enough that a purely financial motive will not sustain the founder through it.
  4. A business plan optimised for an exit produces different decisions from one built around a proposition the founder cares about.
  5. A founder, a chief executive and an investor want different things from a company, and confusing the roles produces bad decisions.
  6. Passion in Komisar's usage means caring about the problem rather than enthusiasm about the opportunity, and the two are frequently confused.
  7. The question of what you would do with your life if you were not doing this should be answered before the company is started rather than after.
  8. The book offers an argument about motivation rather than any method for building a business.

Who should read it

Founders deciding what company to build and anyone operating on a plan to do what they want after some future financial event.

Where it sits in the reference 0

No entry holds this book yet. It reached the reference because someone recommended it.

Who recommended it 5 · 1 direct

Book Notes & Reviews — nateliason.com
Ev Williamsreported
Book recommendations listed on their Good Books profile · aggregator only
Fred Wilsonreported
Superbook reading list
“A recommended entrepreneurship read surfaced in his AVC book discussions.”
Keith Raboisreported
Book recommendations listed on their Good Books profile · aggregator only
Simon Sinekreported
Book recommendations listed on their Good Books profile · aggregator only

Similar books 6

Chosen by shared topics, the entries that hold them, and the people who recommended both.

Atlas Shrugged
Atlas ShruggedAyn Rand
Man's Search for Meaning
Man's Search for MeaningViktor E. Frankl
The Almanack of Naval Ravikant
The Almanack of Naval RavikantEric Jorgenson
Amusing Ourselves to Death
Amusing Ourselves to DeathNeil Postman
Finite and Infinite Games
Finite and Infinite GamesJames P. Carse
Get Back in the Box
Get Back in the BoxDouglas Rushkoff