The Investor's Shelf — one book
Amusing Ourselves to Death

Amusing Ourselves to Death

Neil Postman
1985
T1 195 pages · about 3h 15m to read OL137916Wgoodreads

Television as a medium that reshapes public discourse into entertainment

Summary

Postman argues that the form of a medium determines what kind of content it can carry, and that the shift from print to television changed public discourse from exposition to entertainment. His framing device is the contrast between Orwell, who feared information would be withheld, and Huxley, who feared people would be given so much amusement that they would stop caring, and Postman argues that Huxley was right.

His historical section documents what he calls the age of exposition. He uses the Lincoln and Douglas debates, in which audiences listened to seven hours of complex argument, as evidence that print-based culture produced a public capable of following extended reasoning. He argues that typography imposes a linear, propositional and analytical structure on thought, and that a culture organised around reading develops different cognitive habits than one organised around images.

The television section argues that the medium requires entertainment, that this is not a failure of programming but a property of the form, and that applying it to news, politics, religion and education degrades all four. His treatment of news as a sequence of decontextualised fragments introduced by the phrase now this is the most cited passage. He also argues that television advertising replaced argument about products with images about consumers.

The book was published in 1985 and its predictions about political discourse anticipated much of what followed on the internet, which Postman did not live to analyse. Critics argue that he romanticises the print era, that the Lincoln and Douglas audiences were not typical, and that he underestimates television's capacity for serious work. The argument that the medium constrains the content is the durable contribution.

Key takeaways 8

  1. The form of a medium determines what kind of content it can carry, so a change in medium changes what public discourse can contain.
  2. Print imposes linear, propositional and analytical structure on thought, and a reading culture develops different cognitive habits than an image culture.
  3. Television requires entertainment as a condition of the form, which means applying it to news, politics, religion or education degrades each of them.
  4. News delivered as a sequence of decontextualised fragments produces the sensation of being informed without the substance of it.
  5. Information disconnected from any action a person can take is not information in any useful sense, which Postman argues describes most news consumption.
  6. Political persuasion moved from argument about positions to images about the candidate, which follows from the medium rather than from any decline in politicians.
  7. Huxley's fear that people would be pacified by amusement describes the situation better than Orwell's fear that information would be suppressed.
  8. Postman romanticises the print era and the Lincoln and Douglas audiences he cites were not representative of the public generally.

Who should read it

Readers thinking about how digital platforms shape discourse, who want the argument that the medium constrains the content rather than merely carrying it.

Where it sits in the reference 1

Business models

Who recommended it 6 · 1 direct

Book Notes & Reviews — nateliason.com
Keith Raboisreported
Book recommendations listed on their Good Books profile · aggregator only
Book recommendations listed on their Good Books profile · aggregator only
Book recommendations listed on their Good Books profile · aggregator only
Books O'Shaughnessy has recommended on Invest Like the Best and in his newsletter · aggregator only
Book recommendations listed on their Good Books profile · aggregator only

Similar books 6

Chosen by shared topics, the entries that hold them, and the people who recommended both.

Chaos Monkeys
Chaos MonkeysAntonio Garcia Martinez
The Age of Surveillance Capitalism
The Age of Surveillance CapitalismShoshana Zuboff
The Attention Merchants
The Attention MerchantsTim Wu
Homo Deus
Homo DeusYuval Noah Harari
Sapiens
SapiensYuval Noah Harari
The Curse of the Mogul
The Curse of the MogulJonathan A. Knee, Bruce C. Greenwald