The Investor's Shelf — one book
Dark Shadows: Inside the Secret World of Kaz

Dark Shadows: Inside the Secret World of Kazakhstan

Joanna Lillis
2019
T3 288 pages · about 4h 48m to read OL21336817Wgoodreads

Reporting on the succession, Zhanaozen and how the state and business interlock.

Summary

Lillis, a journalist based in Kazakhstan for many years, wrote a portrait of the country during and immediately after Nursultan Nazarbayev's presidency, built from reporting across the country.

The political material covers the system Nazarbayev built after 1991: personal rule through a presidential apparatus, control of the media, the marginalisation of opposition through prosecution and exile, the elections that returned implausible majorities, and the family's position across business and government. Lillis covers the 2011 Zhanaozen events, in which police fired on striking oil workers, and the prosecutions that followed.

The economic material covers the oil dependence, the wealth concentrated among a small connected group, the sovereign fund and its management, and the offshore structures through which assets were held, which became visible through litigation and through leaks.

The social material is the strongest part and is what distinguishes the book from a political analysis. Lillis reports from across the country on questions the political coverage omits: the position of ethnic Russians in a state pursuing Kazakh national identity, the treatment of language, the legacy of Soviet nuclear testing at Semipalatinsk, the Aral Sea's destruction, the situation of ethnic Kazakhs returning from abroad, and the religious environment.

The book is journalism and does not attempt economic or political science analysis. It was published in 2019, shortly after Nazarbayev's resignation as president while retaining other positions, and before the January 2022 unrest that produced a violent crackdown and the removal of the Nazarbayev family from its remaining positions. Readers should treat it as a portrait of the system as it stood rather than as a current account.

Key takeaways 7

  1. Kazakhstan was governed through personal presidential rule with elections that returned implausible majorities.
  2. Oil dependence concentrated wealth among a small group connected to the presidency.
  3. Assets were held through offshore structures whose existence became visible through litigation and leaks rather than through disclosure.
  4. Police fired on striking oil workers at Zhanaozen in 2011, and the prosecutions that followed targeted the strikers.
  5. The state pursued Kazakh national identity while managing a large ethnic Russian population, which shaped language and citizenship policy.
  6. Soviet nuclear testing at Semipalatinsk and the destruction of the Aral Sea left environmental and health consequences that persist.
  7. The book describes the system before the 2022 unrest that removed the ruling family from its remaining positions.

Who should read it

Investors and operators in Central Asia who need the political and social context behind a resource-dependent personalised state.

Where it sits in the reference 2

Countries
Countries

Similar books 6

Chosen by shared topics, the entries that hold them, and the people who recommended both.

Dictators Without Borders: Power and Money i
Dictators Without Borders: Power and Money in Central AsiaAlexander Cooley, John Heathershaw
Kazakhstan: Unfulfilled Promise
Kazakhstan: Unfulfilled PromiseMartha Brill Olcott
Kleptopia
KleptopiaTom Burgis
The Oil and the Glory
The Oil and the GlorySteve LeVine
Restless Valley
Restless ValleyPhilip Shishkin
Great Games, Local Rules
Great Games, Local RulesAlexander Cooley