The Investor's Shelf — one book
The Key Man

The Key Man

Simon Clark, Will Louch
2021
T4 177 pages · about 2h 57m to read OL24513669Wgoodreads

Summary

Clark and Louch, both Wall Street Journal reporters, reconstruct the rise and collapse of Abraaj Group, the Dubai-based private equity firm founded by Arif Naqvi that became the largest buyout manager in emerging markets before failing in 2018. The reporting rests on internal documents, bank records, court filings and interviews with former employees and investors.

The argument is that impact-investing language and elite endorsement substituted for diligence. Naqvi raised money from the Gates Foundation, the World Bank's IFC, Britain's CDC and large sovereign and pension investors partly on the promise that private capital would deliver healthcare and development returns together. He spoke at Davos, sat on United Nations panels and collected the approval that came with those platforms. Meanwhile, the authors show, Abraaj moved money between funds and the management company, drew down capital for deals that had not closed, and used the healthcare fund's undeployed cash to cover its own expenses.

The collapse came when four investors in the health fund, including the Gates Foundation, hired forensic accountants to trace where their money had gone. The firm went into liquidation, Naqvi was arrested in London and fought extradition to the United States.

The book is journalism rather than analysis, so it is stronger on narrative than on what emerging-market private equity should have done differently. Naqvi has denied the charges and the legal process was unresolved when the book appeared, which readers should hold in mind.

Key takeaways 7

  1. Development finance institutions and foundations invested in Abraaj partly on reputational signals rather than on financial diligence.
  2. Commingling fund capital with management company operations is the specific mechanism that turned Abraaj's cash squeeze into fraud allegations.
  3. Impact-investing labels reduced the scrutiny that a conventional buyout fund of the same size would have attracted.
  4. Capital calls made before deals closed gave the firm working capital it was not entitled to hold.
  5. The fraud was uncovered by limited partners hiring forensic accountants, not by auditors, regulators or the firm's board.
  6. Abraaj's reported returns depended on valuation marks on unsold positions that investors could not independently verify.
  7. Appearances at Davos and on United Nations panels functioned as a substitute for third-party verification of the firm's claims.

Who should read it

Limited partners and fund allocators who want a concrete account of how a large emerging-market manager failed and which specific checks would have caught it.

Where it sits in the reference 2

Companies
Assets

Who recommended it 1 · 1 direct

Bookshelf

Similar books 6

Chosen by shared topics, the entries that hold them, and the people who recommended both.

A Bull in China
A Bull in ChinaJim Rogers
Adventure Capitalist
Adventure CapitalistJim Rogers
Breakout Nations
Breakout NationsRuchir Sharma
Emerging Markets in an Upside Down World
Emerging Markets in an Upside Down WorldJerome Booth
Frontier: Exploring the Top Ten Emerging Mar
Frontier: Exploring the Top Ten Emerging Markets of TomorrowGavin Serkin
Frontier Investor
Frontier InvestorMarko Dimitrijevic, Timothy Mistele