The Investor's Shelf — one book
Winner Sells All

Winner Sells All

Jason Del Rey
2023
T3 OL29046526Wgoodreads

Amazon against Walmart; the retail war told as strategy.

Summary

Jason Del Rey covered Amazon and retail for years and wrote this account of the competition between Amazon and Walmart, framed as the defining commercial rivalry of the period.

The reporting covers both sides. On Amazon he covers the Prime programme and its effect on customer behaviour, the marketplace and the treatment of third-party sellers whose fees became a major profit source, the logistics buildout that made same-day and next-day delivery possible, the pricing algorithms, and the acquisition of Whole Foods. On Walmart he covers the acquisition of Jet.com and Marc Lore's role, the internal conflict between the digital operation and the stores, the use of the store network for fulfilment and pickup, the Flipkart acquisition in India, and the successive strategic reversals.

Del Rey's analytical points are that Amazon's advantage came from being willing to lose money for a decade on capabilities that competitors could not fund, and that Walmart's advantage is the store network as a distribution asset that Amazon cannot replicate. He also covers the labour and seller relations at both companies. The book is well sourced and reported. It is journalism rather than analysis and does not model the economics of either business, and the competitive situation continues to change.

Key takeaways 7

  1. Amazon's advantage came from a willingness to lose money for a decade building capabilities competitors could not fund.
  2. Prime changed customer behaviour by converting delivery from a per-transaction decision into a sunk annual cost.
  3. Third-party seller fees became a major profit source, which makes the marketplace a different business from retail.
  4. Walmart's store network is a distribution asset that Amazon cannot replicate, and its use for fulfilment was the strategic response.
  5. Walmart's digital operation and its stores were in internal conflict, which produced successive strategic reversals.
  6. Acquiring Jet.com bought Walmart executive talent and a digital culture rather than a business worth its price.
  7. The book is reported journalism and does not model the economics of either business.

Who should read it

Investors and operators in retail and logistics who want reported detail on how the two largest retailers actually competed.

Where it sits in the reference 2

Biographies
Industries

Similar books 6

Chosen by shared topics, the entries that hold them, and the people who recommended both.

Amazon Unbound
Amazon UnboundBrad Stone
Bezonomics
BezonomicsBrian Dumaine
Fulfillment
FulfillmentAlec MacGillis
One Click
One ClickRichard L. Brandt
The Everything Store
The Everything StoreBrad Stone
Working Backwards
Working BackwardsColin Bryar, Bill Carr