How deregulated wholesale power markets put the grid's reliability at risk.
Deregulated wholesale markets and reliability risk.
Meredith Angwin, a chemist who managed projects at the Electric Power Research Institute and served for four years on the consumer liaison committee of ISO New England, argues that the deregulated wholesale electricity markets created in the 1990s have made the American grid more expensive and more fragile. Before deregulation, vertically integrated utilities owned generation, transmission and distribution and were answerable for reliability. In areas run by Regional Transmission Organizations and Independent System Operators, she argues, no single body is responsible for reliability: not the RTO, not FERC, not the plants and not the states.
She explains the five-minute auctions in which every plant is paid the clearing price set by the last plant needed, the rule that capital costs cannot enter a bid while subsidies such as Renewable Energy Certificates can, and the capacity markets on which gas plants depend. She compares RTO markets to pre-2008 mortgage lending, cites a University of Chicago estimate that renewable portfolio standards cost consumers $125 billion, and finds prices higher in RTO areas than under regulated monopolies. Her case for fuel diversity and on-site fuel storage favours nuclear and coal plants.
Investors in utilities and power generation, and anyone following energy policy, who need a plain account of how wholesale electricity markets set prices and who answers for reliability.
Chosen by shared topics, the entries that hold them, and the people who recommended both.
Edison, Westinghouse and Tesla, and the fight to electrify the United States.
“I mean, the airplane, the car, the photograph, the light bulb, for God's sake, this amazing book called Empires of Light.” — Chris Dixon
Recommended by: Chris Dixon
Samuel Insull, from Edison's secretary to Chicago utility empire to fugitive.
The American electrical grid as a physical and social system, and why it is strained.
“And then another book I'm reading, which was actually a Bill Gates recommendation is, it's called The Grid about the electric grid, which is also pretty good.” — Mohnish Pabrai
Source: Pabrai Investment Funds Annual Meeting Transcript 2018, page 21
Recommended by: Mohnish Pabrai
How the world can meet its growing energy demand and keep the biosphere intact.
Recommended by: Bill Gates
The young readers' edition of the case on global warming and the greenhouse effect.
Recommended by: Richard Branson
How ownership of American agriculture came to sit with a few families and firms.