Don't Count on It!
Summary
Bogle collected his speeches, articles and essays from across his career into a volume organised by theme: investment illusion versus reality, the failure of capitalism's institutions, the mutual fund industry, indexing, entrepreneurship and innovation, idealism and the new generation, and personal heroes.
The analytical content restates arguments he made repeatedly. The mathematics of costs, in which investors as a group must earn the market return less all costs, so the average managed dollar must underperform the index by the amount of the costs. The distinction between investment return, meaning dividends plus earnings growth, and speculative return, meaning change in the valuation multiple, and his argument that the first is forecastable within a range while the second is not. The critique of what he calls the double agency problem, in which fund managers who should represent investors instead act as owners' agents while corporate managers act for themselves, leaving nobody representing the actual owners.
The title essay attacks the reliance on numbers, arguing that what can be counted in finance, including reported earnings, published returns and risk measures, is systematically less reliable than practitioners assume and that the things that determine outcomes are largely uncountable.
The collection is long and repetitive, since the pieces were written separately over decades and restate the same positions. Readers new to Bogle should start with The Little Book of Common Sense Investing. This volume's use is having the arguments in their fuller original forms with the data he assembled.
Key takeaways 7
- Investors as a group earn the market return less all costs, so the average actively managed dollar must underperform the index by the amount of those costs.
- Equity return decomposes into investment return, meaning dividends and earnings growth, and speculative return, meaning multiple change, and only the first is forecastable.
- The double agency problem leaves nobody representing the actual owners, since fund managers and corporate managers each act for themselves.
- What can be counted in finance, including reported earnings and published returns, is less reliable than practitioners assume.
- Index fund performance advantage derives from arithmetic rather than from any theory about market efficiency.
- Fund industry marketing sells past performance, which has no predictive content, while costs, which do predict, are not marketed at all.
- Financial institutions became asset gatherers rather than stewards, and the change followed from the shift to public ownership of fund management companies.
Who should read it
Investors who want Bogle's arguments in their fuller original forms, though newcomers should start with his shorter books.
About John C. Bogle
Founder and CEO, The Vanguard Group 1974-1996; creator of the first retail index mutual fund
He built the institution and wrote the primary-source case for low-cost indexing that every later index advocate builds on.
Who recommended it 1
Similar books 6
Chosen by shared topics, the entries that hold them, and the people who recommended both.
Vanguard's founder on costs, turnover and fund structure.
“Wonderful Book. I highly recommend all of John Bogle's writings to any investor.” — Mohnish Pabrai
Source: Mohnish's Bookshelf — Books on Investing & Capital Allocation, entry 50
Recommended by: Mohnish Pabrai, Jason Zweig and 3 others
Founder account of Vanguard, the mutual structure applied to fund management.
Recommended by: Mr. Money Mustache
How speculation displaced long-term investment in markets, shown in turnover data.
“I also recommend The Clash of the Cultures by Jack Bogle” — Warren Buffett
Source: 2012 Berkshire Hathaway Shareholder Letter, p. 21
Recommended by: Mohnish Pabrai, Warren Buffett and 1 other
Recommended by: Mr. Money Mustache
Fifty years of speeches and essays arguing for low-cost index funds.
Recommended by: Mohnish Pabrai, Mr. Money Mustache
After costs, most investors trail the market, so hold a low-cost index fund.
Recommended by: Mohnish Pabrai, The Barefoot Investor and 4 others
Where it sits in the reference 2
Topics