
Net asset value and resource conversion as the real drivers of investment return.
Net asset value and resource conversion as the real drivers of return.
Whitman ran Third Avenue Value Fund and wrote from the position of a control investor and distressed securities specialist rather than that of a stock picker. His argument is a direct challenge to the Graham and Dodd tradition as commonly practised.
His first claim is that conventional security analysis overweights the income statement. Graham-influenced investors focus on going-concern earnings and dividends, which is the correct frame only for a passive minority investor in an operating business that will continue as it is. Whitman argues that most companies are better analysed through the balance sheet, because assets can be sold, refinanced, spun off or used as collateral, and because the range of outcomes for a company includes takeover, liquidation, recapitalisation and reorganisation as well as continued operation. He calls these outcomes resource conversion and treats them as normal rather than exceptional.
His second claim is that the analyst must know which type of investor they are. An outside passive minority investor faces different information, different rights and different economics from a control investor, and applying the wrong frame produces wrong conclusions. Much of academic finance, in his view, models the first while the actual determinants of value come from the second.
His practical standard is safe and cheap: buy companies with strong financial position, meaning little debt and substantial liquid assets, with honest and competent management, with understandable disclosure, and at a large discount to readily ascertainable net asset value.
The writing is dense and unstructured, and Whitman assumes familiarity with securities law, bankruptcy and accounting. His approach performed poorly in the decade after the financial crisis, when asset-heavy discounted companies stayed discounted, and his dismissal of earnings power looks less persuasive in an economy where the most valuable businesses hold few tangible assets.
Investors working in distressed debt, control situations or asset-heavy companies who want the balance sheet case against earnings-based value investing.
Founder and Chairman, Third Avenue Management; portfolio manager, Third Avenue Value Fund 1990-2012
Four books plus three decades of unusually didactic shareholder letters built out safe-and-cheap and distress investing as a distinct branch of the value tradition.
Chosen by shared topics, the entries that hold them, and the people who recommended both.
Safe and cheap investing: a security can be both lower-risk and higher-return.
“Joel Greenblatt’s You Can Be a Stock Market Genius6 is tactical and includes some very specific and interesting strategies, and The Aggressive Conservative Investor,7 by Marty Whitman and Martin Shubik, is also very interesting.” — Seth Klarman
Source: Opportunities for Patient Investors (Klarman-Zweig interview, Financial Analysts Journal), page 11
Recommended by: Guy Spier, Mohnish Pabrai, Seth Klarman
Security analysis that weighs the balance sheet over reported earnings.
Recommended by: Mohnish Pabrai
Avoid permanent loss: buy well below value and aim for absolute returns.
“Seth Klarman, the founder, chief executive, and portfolio manager of the very successful value investing firm The Baupost Group, shares a similar sentiment in his book Margin of Safety:22 It is not clear why investors suddenly came to accept EBITDA as a measure of corporate cash flow.” — Michael Mauboussin
Source: What Does an EV/EBITDA Multiple Mean?, page 4
Recommended by: Arnold Van Den Berg, Frank Martin, Guy Spier and 7 others
Treat stocks as parts of businesses and buy only with a margin of safety.
“Although I’ve been reading The Intelligent Investor on a regular basis over the years, I never reread the 1958 speech, until I came across a Latin quote from Ben Graham and searched far and wide for its origin.” — Francois Rochon
Source: Giverny Capital Annual Letter to Partners 2018, page 9
Recommended by: Benjamin Graham, Christopher Bloomstran and 32 others
How to read financial statements sceptically and value bonds and stocks.
“I am reminded once again of the quote that sits in the front of Ben Graham’s Security Analysis, from Horace’s Ars Poetica: “Many shall be restored that now are fallen and many shall fall that now are in honor.” — Bill Miller
Source: 2007 Q3 Market Commentary
Recommended by: Bill Miller, Christopher Bloomstran and 18 others
How to find genuinely undervalued stocks before anyone else.
Recommended by: Mohnish Pabrai
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.