The official report on why Long-Term Capital Management failed.
Primary source: the official post-mortem.
The President's Working Group on Financial Markets, comprising the Treasury, the Federal Reserve, the Securities and Exchange Commission and the Commodity Futures Trading Commission, produced this report in April 1999 following the near-failure of Long-Term Capital Management the previous September.
The report's analysis identifies the central issue as leverage rather than hedge funds as such. Long-Term Capital had balance sheet leverage of roughly twenty-five to one before its losses and far higher afterward, plus derivative positions with notional values in the trillions that did not appear on the balance sheet at all. The report finds that this leverage was extended by the fund's counterparties, who were the major banks and securities firms, and that those counterparties had failed to obtain adequate information about the fund's overall positions, had competed for its business by offering favourable terms including low or zero initial margin, and had each assessed their own exposure without knowing the aggregate.
The conclusions follow from this. The report declines to recommend direct regulation of hedge funds, on the grounds that the effective constraint on leverage is the willingness of counterparties to extend it. Instead it recommends improved counterparty risk management including better information from funds, stress testing against extreme scenarios rather than only historical volatility, more conservative collateral practices, greater public disclosure by publicly traded financial institutions of their exposures, and consideration of regulatory capital rules that reflect counterparty leverage.
The report is an official document and reads as one: measured, consensus-driven and reluctant to recommend anything contested.
Its central recommendations were not implemented in any binding form, and the 2008 crisis reproduced the same failures at far greater scale: leverage extended without knowledge of aggregate positions, risk measured against historical volatility, and collateral practices that tightened simultaneously. The report is worth reading as evidence that the mechanism was correctly diagnosed nine years before it mattered.
Risk managers and regulators who want the official diagnosis of leverage and counterparty failure, and evidence of how long a correct diagnosis can go unacted on.
Chosen by shared topics, the entries that hold them, and the people who recommended both.
Long-Term Capital Management's actual positions, and the option theory behind them.
How a hedge fund's bond bets on borrowed money lost $4.6 billion in four months.
“Roger Lowenstein, When Genius Failed: The Rise and Fall of Long-Term Capital Management (New York: Random House, 2000), 72” — Michael Mauboussin
Source: A Tail of Two Worlds: Fat Tails and Investing, page 4
Recommended by: Bill Gurley, Michael Mauboussin and 9 others
How financial innovation made markets more crisis-prone, from a risk manager.
“The New York Times of August 18 described A Demon of Our Own Design, by Richard Bookstaber (see “Investment Miscellany,” November 2000) as pointing out that “the proliferation of complex financial products like derivatives, combined with use of leverage to bolster returns, will inevitably mean that there will be a regular stream of market contagions like the one we’re having now – one of which, someday, could be calamitous.” 6” — Howard Marks
Source: Now It’s All Bad?, page 6
Recommended by: Howard Marks, Jeremy Grantham and 1 other
Fischer Black's life and ideas, from option pricing on, that shaped modern finance.
Recommended by: Mohnish Pabrai
Life on Salomon Brothers' bond trading floor in the 1980s mortgage-bond boom.
“And then "Liar's Poker" from Michael Lewis, love that. I really like - I mythologize like Lewis Ranieri and all these guys when I read it.” — Chamath Palihapitiya
Source: Transcript: Chamath Palihapitiya
Recommended by: Chamath Palihapitiya, Michael Burry and 5 others
Hedge funds from Alfred Winslow Jones in 1949 through Soros, Robertson and beyond.
“It's hard to imagine anyone will ever write a better book on the subject.” — Paul Graham
Source: Paul Graham on X (Apr 8, 2021)
Recommended by: Mohnish Pabrai, Paul Graham, Tim Ferriss and 1 other
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.