Why the cheapest stocks on enterprise value to operating earnings beat other screens.
Short popular version of the enterprise-value-to-operating-earnings screen.
Tobias Carlisle argues that the simplest measure of cheapness outperforms more sophisticated value approaches, and that the specific measure to use is enterprise value divided by operating earnings, which he calls the acquirer's multiple because it is what a buyer of the whole business would look at.
His argument against quality-adjusted value is the more interesting part. Joel Greenblatt's magic formula combines cheapness with return on capital, and Carlisle's backtests find that the cheapness component alone outperforms the combination. His explanation is mean reversion: high returns on capital attract competition and decline, low returns attract exit and improve, and paying for current quality means paying for a characteristic that will erode. Buying cheapness alone means buying businesses whose current results are poor and whose future results will be better than the price implies.
He supports this with backtests, with the academic literature on value and on mean reversion, and with the behaviour of activist investors, who target exactly the cheap companies with poor current returns and force the change. He also covers Buffett's evolution from Graham's statistical cheapness toward quality, and argues that Buffett's approach works for Buffett because of scale and permanence rather than because it dominates generally. The backtests are the author's own and the sample periods are chosen by him, which readers should discount. The book is short and the argument is clearly stated and testable, which is more than most investment books offer.
Value investors deciding between deep value and quality approaches who want a clearly stated and testable argument for the former.
Australian-born fund manager and founder of Acquirers Funds; writes on deep-value screening and systematic value investing.
Deep Value examines why the cheapest, most beaten-down companies outperform higher-quality compounders on average, and traces the activist and liquidation history behind that result. The Acquirer's Multiple sets out the enterprise-value-to-operating-earnings screen he runs, and Quantitative Value tests value rules against the data with the discretionary error removed.
Chosen by shared topics, the entries that hold them, and the people who recommended both.
The evidence that buying cheap, troubled companies beats more refined methods.
Recommended by: Mohnish Pabrai, Patrick O'Shaughnessy
A systematic value strategy, built and backtested piece by piece.
How to read financial statements sceptically and value bonds and stocks.
“I am reminded once again of the quote that sits in the front of Ben Graham’s Security Analysis, from Horace’s Ars Poetica: “Many shall be restored that now are fallen and many shall fall that now are in honor.” — Bill Miller
Source: 2007 Q3 Market Commentary
Recommended by: Bill Miller, Christopher Bloomstran and 18 others
Treat stocks as parts of businesses and buy only with a margin of safety.
“Although I’ve been reading The Intelligent Investor on a regular basis over the years, I never reread the 1958 speech, until I came across a Latin quote from Ben Graham and searched far and wide for its origin.” — Francois Rochon
Source: Giverny Capital Annual Letter to Partners 2018, page 9
Recommended by: Benjamin Graham, Christopher Bloomstran and 32 others
Safe and cheap investing: a security can be both lower-risk and higher-return.
“Joel Greenblatt’s You Can Be a Stock Market Genius6 is tactical and includes some very specific and interesting strategies, and The Aggressive Conservative Investor,7 by Marty Whitman and Martin Shubik, is also very interesting.” — Seth Klarman
Source: Opportunities for Patient Investors (Klarman-Zweig interview, Financial Analysts Journal), page 11
Recommended by: Guy Spier, Mohnish Pabrai, Seth Klarman
Columbia's value investing method: a valuation in three stages, most reliable first.
“In the book, Value Investing–From Graham to Buffett and Beyond, by Greenwald, Kahn, Sonkin and Van Biema, there are discussions of NAV.” — Martin J. Whitman
Source: Third Avenue Funds Q3 2003 Shareholder Letters (Chairman's letter by Martin J. Whitman)
Recommended by: Martin J. Whitman, Michael Mauboussin and 5 others
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.