Flash Boys
The IEX story and the public argument about latency arbitrage.
Summary
Lewis follows Brad Katsuyama, a Royal Bank of Canada trader who discovered that his orders were being front-run, and his effort to understand the mechanism and then to build IEX, an exchange designed to prevent it.
The mechanism Lewis describes is latency arbitrage. When a large order is routed to multiple exchanges, it arrives at the nearest one first. Firms with faster connections observe the execution there and trade ahead of the order's arrival at the other venues, moving the price against the original buyer. Lewis documents the infrastructure built for this, including a fibre line laid in a straight route between Chicago and New Jersey to reduce transmission time by a few milliseconds, and microwave towers built afterwards for the same purpose.
He also covers payment for order flow, the proliferation of order types designed to advantage particular participants, dark pools operated by banks whose interests conflicted with their clients', and the effect of Regulation NMS in creating the fragmented structure that made the arbitrage possible. IEX's response was a coil of fibre creating a delay that removed the speed advantage on incoming orders.
The book was heavily disputed. Critics argue that Lewis overstates the harm to ordinary investors, that spreads and costs have fallen substantially for retail investors, that high-frequency market making provides liquidity, and that the rigged claim is a simplification. Lewis concentrates on a single perspective and the technical description has been challenged on specifics. The description of latency arbitrage and of market fragmentation is accurate in outline.
Key takeaways 8
- A large order routed to multiple exchanges arrives at the nearest one first, which lets observers trade ahead of its arrival elsewhere.
- Firms built physical infrastructure including a straight fibre route and microwave towers to reduce transmission time by milliseconds.
- Regulation NMS created a fragmented market structure in which orders must be routed across venues, which is what made the arbitrage possible.
- Order types were created that advantage particular participants, and their existence was not widely understood even by professional traders.
- Banks operated dark pools while also routing client orders, which created a conflict most clients could not observe.
- An exchange can remove a speed advantage by introducing a deliberate delay on incoming orders, which is the mechanism IEX built.
- Payment for order flow means retail orders are sold rather than routed to the venue offering the best execution.
- Critics argue that retail trading costs have fallen substantially and that the harm Lewis describes falls on institutions rather than on ordinary investors.
Who should read it
Investors who want an account of market structure and latency arbitrage, read alongside the substantial technical criticism it received.
About Michael Lewis
Financial journalist and author; former Salomon Brothers bond salesman
Liar's Poker, The Big Short and Flash Boys are the primary narrative sources later writers build on for Wall Street of the 1980s, the subprime crisis and high-frequency trading.
Who recommended it 2 · 2 direct
Similar books 6
Chosen by shared topics, the entries that hold them, and the people who recommended both.
Execution algorithms and direct market access, from the desk.
A trader in his parents' London house, and his link to the 2010 flash crash.
GameStop and Citadel Securities' order flow; dramatised.
Popular account of algorithms taking over trading and other trades.
Life on Salomon Brothers' bond trading floor in the 1980s mortgage-bond boom.
“I do believe, as Michael Lewis writes in his intriguing 1989 book, "Liar's Poker," that it is unlikely that an individual unable to buck convention in one's life will suddenly be able to buck…” — Michael Burry
Source: MSN Money Strategy Lab journal, March 2, 2001 — archived
Recommended by: Michael Burry, Mohnish Pabrai, Nat Eliason and 3 others
Where it sits in the reference 2
Topics