Quantitative Value: A Practitioner's Guide to Automating Intelligent Investment and Eliminating Behavioral Errors

Gray and Carlisle build a systematic value strategy from the ground up and backtest each component. They start from the observation that Joel Greenblatt's magic formula and Piotroski's F-score both work, then decompose the problem into four steps: avoid permanent loss, screen for quality, buy cheap, and confirm with signals from informed parties.

The screening architecture is specific. They use accruals and financial distress measures, including a probability-of-bankruptcy model, to eliminate candidates with accounting manipulation or default risk. They compare quality metrics and conclude that returns on capital measured with the Greenblatt definition and a franchise-strength assessment beat alternatives. On valuation they test the common multiples against each other and find enterprise value to operating earnings outperforms price to book, price to earnings, and free cash flow yield over their sample. They then add confirming signals from insider buying, short interest and institutional activity. The backtests run from 1974 to 2011 on United States data.

The book's real argument is not about which factor wins but about process. Gray and Carlisle marshal the evidence from Meehl onward that simple statistical models beat expert judgement, and argue that the correct role for a value investor is to build the model and then not override it. That claim is the most useful part and the most resisted. The weaknesses are the usual ones for backtested research: the sample is a single country over a specific regime, the results are sensitive to how survivorship and delisting returns are handled, and value factors performed poorly for most of the decade after publication, which the book's confidence does not prepare a reader for.

Founder and CEO, Alpha Architect; formerly assistant professor of finance at Drexel University's LeBow College of Business; former U.S. Marine Corps captain

Quantitative Value and Quantitative Momentum are the standard build-it-yourself manuals for systematic value and momentum, and Alpha Architect is a heavily used practitioner research archive.

Alpha Architect, Drexel University, U.S. Marine Corps