
Voters hold systematic biases about economics, so democracies choose bad policies.
Systematic voter bias about economics, and why democracies choose badly
Caplan argues that democracy produces bad economic policy not because voters are ignorant, which the standard rational ignorance literature already accepts, but because they hold systematically mistaken beliefs that they prefer to hold. He calls this rational irrationality: since an individual vote has essentially zero probability of changing an outcome, the private cost of holding a comfortable false belief is nearly zero, so people indulge beliefs they would abandon if they bore the consequences.
His evidence is the Survey of Americans and Economists on the Economy, which asked the same economic questions of the general public and of professional economists. He identifies four systematic biases where the public differs from economists in a consistent direction: anti-market bias, underestimating the benefits of market mechanisms; anti-foreign bias, underestimating the benefits of trade with foreigners; make-work bias, treating employment rather than production as the goal; and pessimistic bias, systematically believing conditions are worse and worsening. He controls for income, education, ideology and other factors and finds the gaps persist.
His conclusions are uncomfortable and he states them plainly: more democracy is not the remedy for bad policy, and insulating economic decisions from voter preference, through independent central banks, trade agreements or judicial constraint, produces better outcomes.
The main objection is that Caplan treats the economics profession's consensus as the standard of truth, which is defensible on some questions and not on others, and the 2008 crisis complicated that assumption. The empirical finding that public and expert opinion diverge systematically has held up.
Investors and policy readers who want the public choice account of why democratic economic policy is systematically distorted.
“A critical look at democracy. I love the way he thinks so it’s fun to hear his thought process even though I’m not that interested in this subject.”
“The median American is a moderate national socialist – statist to the core on both economic and social policy.”
Chosen by shared topics, the entries that hold them, and the people who recommended both.
Economic freedom as a condition of political freedom, applied to policy questions.
“During the quarter, I reread three volumes authored by great economists: The General Theory of Employment, Interest and Money by John Maynard Keynes, The Road to Serfdom by F. A. Hayek, and Capitalism and Freedom by Milton Friedman.” — Martin J. Whitman
Source: Third Avenue Funds Q4 2005 Shareholder Letters (Chairman's letter by Martin J. Whitman)
Recommended by: Martin J. Whitman, Marc Andreessen
The case for free markets and limited government, policy area by policy area.
Recommended by: Brian Armstrong, Jim Collins, Mohnish Pabrai and 2 others
How communities manage shared resources without either the state or the market.
Recommended by: Patrick Collison, Stewart Brand
How leaders of dictatorships and democracies gain and keep power.
Recommended by: Nat Eliason, Andrew Chen, Marc Andreessen
An inquiry into the nature of freedom and the uses of power.
Recommended by: Marc Andreessen
The case for anarcho-capitalism, a society run on markets without a state.
Recommended by: Marc Andreessen
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.