Lying
Summary
Harris makes a short and absolute case against lying, including white lies told to spare feelings. His argument is that deception is a form of coercion because it removes the other person's ability to act on accurate information, and that the liar arrogates to themselves the decision about what another person may know. He distinguishes lying from withholding, arguing that a person is not obliged to disclose everything but is obliged not to state what they believe to be false. This allows a great deal of tact without permitting deception.
His practical argument concerns the accumulating costs. A lie requires maintenance, must be remembered, generates further lies to protect it, and creates a permanent risk of discovery that changes the relationship it was meant to protect. He argues that white lies are the most damaging category because they are constant, because they deprive people of information they need, and because the person telling them learns nothing about how the other person would have handled the truth.
He covers specific cases including lying to children about Santa Claus, praising work you think is poor, and the classic murderer at the door problem, which he treats as a genuine exception under conditions of duress against someone who has forfeited their claim to honest dealing.
The book is very short, essentially an essay. It contains no research and Harris offers no empirical evidence about whether honest people fare better. The position is absolutist and Harris does not seriously engage with the strongest objections. Its value is the clarity of the distinction between lying and withholding, which is directly usable in professional situations where the alternative to a lie is assumed to be cruelty.
Key takeaways 8
- Lying is a form of coercion because it removes the other person's ability to act on accurate information.
- A liar decides unilaterally what another person is permitted to know, which is the specific harm regardless of the liar's intention.
- Withholding information is different from stating what you believe to be false, which permits tact without permitting deception.
- White lies are the most damaging category because they are constant and deprive people of information they need to make decisions.
- Every lie requires maintenance, must be remembered, and generates further lies to protect it.
- A relationship built on a lie is not protected by it, since discovery changes the relationship more than the truth would have.
- Telling someone an uncomfortable truth gives them information and also gives you information about how they handle it, which lying forecloses.
- Harris allows exceptions under duress against someone who has forfeited any claim to honest dealing, which is the only case he concedes.
Who should read it
Anyone whose work involves regular feedback, negotiation or difficult conversations, wanting a clear argument and the lying versus withholding distinction.
Who recommended it 6 · 3 direct
Similar books 6
Chosen by shared topics, the entries that hold them, and the people who recommended both.
A novel in which industrialists vanish from an economy run by government directives.
Recommended by: Brian Armstrong, Mohnish Pabrai, Nat Eliason and 18 others
Life in Nazi concentration camps, and logotherapy: finding meaning to survive.
“I have been deeply influenced by the existentialist and eminent psychiatrist Viktor Frankl, who wrote the perennial best seller Man's Search for Meaning, one of the most influential books I've ever…” — Frank Martin
Source: Martin on one of the most influential books he has read and reread
Recommended by: Frank Martin, Mohnish Pabrai, Nat Eliason and 24 others
Twelve rules for living, each drawn from clinical practice, biology and myth.
Recommended by: Nat Eliason, Alex and Books, Ana Fabrega and 7 others
Where it sits in the reference 0
No entry holds this book yet. It reached the reference because someone recommended it.
Topics